Blog · Credentialing
Medical Staff Bylaws: What CMS and The Joint Commission Require Them to Cover

Medical staff bylaws are the rulebook a hospital’s organized medical staff adopts for itself. Medicare makes them a condition of participation: the hospital must have an organized medical staff that operates under bylaws approved by the governing body [1]. This guide covers what 42 CFR 482.22(c) requires the bylaws to contain. It also covers how CMS surveyors read each requirement in the State Operations Manual, and where The Joint Commission’s Medical Staff standards add to the list.
Last verified: November 6, 2026. Facts in this guide are cited to official CMS and Joint Commission sources, listed at the end.
What does CMS require medical staff bylaws to contain?
The medical staff must adopt and enforce bylaws to carry out its responsibilities [1]. The table below pairs each requirement in 42 CFR 482.22(c) with the survey tag a surveyor works from in CMS State Operations Manual Appendix A. It is a summary of the regulation and its interpretive guidance, not legal advice.
| Requirement | What the bylaws must do | Survey tag |
|---|---|---|
| 482.22(c)(1) | Be approved by the governing body. Bylaws and any revisions must be submitted to the governing body, which may approve or disapprove them, and they are not effective until it approves them [1][3]. | A-0354 [3] |
| 482.22(c)(2) | State the duties and privileges of each category of medical staff, such as active and courtesy. The specific privileges for a category must clearly and completely list that category’s privileges or limitations [1][3]. | A-0355 [3] |
| 482.22(c)(3) | Describe the organization of the medical staff, including a mechanism that delineates accountability to the governing body and who reviews members’ clinical work [1][3]. | A-0356 [3] |
| 482.22(c)(4) | Describe the qualifications a candidate must meet for the medical staff to recommend appointment by the governing body [1][3]. | A-0357 [3] |
| 482.22(c)(5) | Require a medical history and physical examination for each patient no more than 30 days before or 24 hours after admission or registration, and before surgery or a procedure requiring anesthesia services, except as provided under 482.22(c)(5)(iii) for specific outpatient surgical or procedural services [1][3]. | A-0358 [3] |
| 482.22(c)(6) | Include criteria for determining the privileges granted to individual practitioners and a procedure for applying those criteria to individuals requesting privileges [1][3]. | A-0363 [3] |
Consistency with State law, and enforcement
Appendix A adds a framing requirement on top of the list: the medical staff must regulate itself by bylaws consistent with this and other conditions of participation that mention medical staff bylaws, as well as with State law, and the bylaws must be enforced and revised as necessary [3]. A surveyor also checks that the bylaws describe a mechanism for enforcing their own provisions [3].
Who adopts medical staff bylaws and who approves them?
These are two separate acts, and both accreditation frameworks keep them separate. Under the Medicare governing body condition, the governing body must assure that the medical staff has bylaws and must approve medical staff bylaws and other medical staff rules and regulations [2]. The Joint Commission’s Medical Staff standard on bylaws adoption states that the organized medical staff adopts and amends the bylaws, that adoption or amendment cannot be delegated, and that after the medical staff acts, the proposed bylaws go to the governing body; bylaws become effective only upon governing body approval [4].
A common question in the medical staff office is whether a formal meeting is required to adopt or amend medical staff bylaws. The Joint Commission’s Standards FAQ on bylaw approval answers that no medical staff standard prescriptively requires a meeting format to review, revise, adopt, or approve the bylaws, and that the format is an organizational decision [5]. What is required is that the medical staff as a whole have the opportunity to review, amend, and vote on any changes, and that the adoption or amendment not be delegated to a committee such as the medical executive committee, which the FAQ ties back to that same bylaws adoption element [5].
Practical consequence for your file: when you document a bylaws amendment, keep two dated records, not one. The first shows the medical staff’s own action on the amendment, and the second shows the governing body’s approval, which is the date the amendment took effect [4][5].
What the bylaws must say about privileging
Appendix A is direct about this: the bylaws must describe the privileging process to be used in the hospital, including criteria for determining privileges and a procedure for applying them that considers individual character, competence, training, experience, and judgment [3]. Those same five selection criteria are what 42 CFR 482.12(a)(6) makes the governing body responsible for [2]. Surveyors verify that the bylaws contain criteria for granting, withdrawing, and modifying clinical privileges, along with a procedure for applying them [3].
Two limits are worth writing into the document in plain words:
- Board certification cannot stand alone. Under 42 CFR 482.12(a)(7), staff membership or professional privileges may under no circumstances depend solely upon certification, fellowship, or membership in a specialty body or society [2]. Appendix A puts the same point in operational terms: the medical staff may require board certification, but may not rely solely on whether an MD or DO is board certified [3].
- A category’s privileges are not granted automatically. Stating the duties and scope of privileges for a category does not mean each practitioner in it gets the full range; each individual practitioner’s ability to perform each task, activity, or privilege must be individually assessed [3]. The bylaws must apply equally to all practitioners in each professional category [3].
What accreditation standards add to the privileging criteria
The Joint Commission’s privileging criteria are more specific about the evidence behind a decision. Its privileging criteria element says the criteria the hospital establishes, on medical staff recommendation and with governing body approval, include evaluation of current licensure or certification, as appropriate, verified with the primary source, the applicant’s specific relevant training verified with the primary source, evidence of physical ability to perform the requested privilege, data from professional practice review by an organization that currently privileges the applicant where available, peer or faculty recommendation, and, at renewal, review of performance within the organization [4]. The Joint Commission also states that the credentialing process itself is approved by the governing body [4].
If your bylaws or their companion policies define who is privileged through the Medical Staff chapter, note that The Joint Commission’s FAQ on physician assistants and advanced practice registered nurses treats any provider recognized by state law who provides services as a Licensed Practitioner, or who provides a medical level of care and decision-making such as writing orders or directing care, as required to be granted privileges before providing care, treatment, or services [6].
The FAQ states that PAs, while generally not recognized as independent practitioners, are subject to the same credentialing and privileging requirements in the Medical Staff chapter, and that the FPPE and OPPE requirements apply to these practitioners as well [6]. The same FAQ adds that when an APRN or PA functions in a limited role, such as an educator, and is not directing care as a licensed independent practitioner, the Medical Staff requirements would not apply [6]. Our guide to credentialing allied health professionals covers the file-building side of that work.
Bylaw provisions medical staff offices most often miss
- A telemedicine reliance provision. Where the governing body opts to rely on a distant-site hospital’s or telemedicine entity’s credentialing and privileging decisions, the medical staff bylaws must include a provision allowing the medical staff to rely upon those decisions, and surveyors check for it [3]. The written agreement requirements sit in 42 CFR 482.12(a)(8) and (a)(9) [2].
- The periodic appraisal process and criteria. The medical staff must periodically conduct appraisals of its members [1], and the survey procedure is to determine whether the bylaws identify the process and criteria used for that periodic appraisal [3]. Where no State law sets a timeframe, CMS recommends an appraisal at least every 24 months for each practitioner; this is a recommendation in the interpretive guidance rather than a stated regulatory deadline, and the duty sits with the hospital’s organized medical staff, which makes recommendations to the governing body [3]. Appendix A also states that a separate credentials file must be maintained for each medical staff member [3]. Our credentialing file audit checklist is a useful companion when you test those files.
Structure and governance provisions
- Executive committee composition. If the medical staff has an executive committee, a majority of its members must be doctors of medicine or osteopathy [1].
- Who may lead the medical staff. Responsibility for the organization and conduct of the medical staff may be assigned only to a doctor of medicine or osteopathy, a doctor of dental surgery or dental medicine where State law permits, or a doctor of podiatric medicine where State law permits [1].
- The unified medical staff vote. Where a system of multiple separately certified hospitals elects to have a unified and integrated medical staff for its member hospitals, each separately certified hospital must demonstrate that its medical staff members have voted by majority, in accordance with medical staff bylaws, either to accept a unified and integrated medical staff structure or to opt out, and the unified staff’s bylaws must describe its processes for self-governance, appointment, credentialing, privileging, and oversight, as well as its peer review policies and its due process rights [1].
- Due process language that matches your peer review practice. For the federal peer review backdrop behind that bylaws requirement [1], see our explainer on the Health Care Quality Improvement Act.
Medical staff bylaws review checklist
Use this as a reading pass over the current document before the next medical executive committee cycle. Each item points back to the rule it tests.
- Confirm the document on your intranet is the version the governing body approved, and that every amendment since carries a governing body approval date [1][3][4].
- Check that each staff category has its duties and its specific privileges or limitations listed, not just a name [1][3].
- Find the sentence that says privileges are assessed individually, and the sentence that says board certification is not the sole factor [2][3].
- Locate the criteria for granting, withdrawing, and modifying clinical privileges, and the procedure for applying them [3].
- Locate the periodic appraisal process and criteria, and compare the interval your bylaws state against your State law and the CMS recommendation of at least every 24 months [3].
- If your hospital relies on distant-site telemedicine credentialing decisions, confirm the reliance provision is actually in the bylaws [3].
- Check that the organization section names accountability to the governing body and who reviews clinical work [3].
- Confirm the enforcement mechanism exists and is described, since surveyors test enforcement, not just the text [3].
Data bank queries and governing body oversight
- Verify your query schedule against 45 CFR 60.17, which requires a hospital, directly or through an authorized agent, to request National Practitioner Data Bank information when a practitioner applies for a medical staff position or clinical privileges and every 2 years for any practitioner on its medical staff or holding privileges [7]. A hospital that does not request the information is presumed to have knowledge of what was reported about that practitioner [7].
- Confirm the governing body’s direct consultation with the individual responsible for the medical staff is happening and documented; 42 CFR 482.12(a)(10) requires it periodically throughout the fiscal or calendar year, including discussion of matters related to the quality of medical care [2].
Where the bylaws set timeframes, your credentialing calendar has to match them. Reappointment cycles, data bank queries, and expirables all live in the same files; the same discipline applies to the documents behind a Medicare enrollment change of information when a practitioner’s privileges change.
Keep bylaw timeframes visible in your credentialing workflow
Incredable lets you create custom workflows that match your organization’s unique credentialing and compliance requirements — Incredable adapts to your process, not the other way around — and generate real-time reports on provider status, workflow progress, and expirations, customizable by facility or user role.
For the verification side of a new appointment, see our walkthrough of nurse license verification for credentialing.
Sources
- eCFR, 42 CFR 482.22, Condition of participation: Medical staff. Verified November 6, 2026.
- eCFR, 42 CFR 482.12, Condition of participation: Governing body. Verified November 6, 2026.
- CMS, State Operations Manual Appendix A, Interpretive Guidelines for Hospitals. Verified November 6, 2026.
- The Joint Commission, Joint Commission Requirements for the Board (Joint Commission Resources, 2023; terms from the Comprehensive Accreditation Manual for Hospitals updated January 2023). Verified November 6, 2026.
- The Joint Commission, Standards FAQ: Medical Staff Bylaw and Amendment Approval Meeting. Verified November 6, 2026.
- The Joint Commission, Standards FAQ: Credentialing and Privileging Requirements for Physician Assistants and APRNs. Verified November 6, 2026.
- eCFR, 45 CFR 60.17, Information which hospitals must request from the NPDB. Verified November 6, 2026.
